Haley grew up in Lawrence, NJ and graduated from Notre Dame HS in 2017. She was a 3-year varsity soccer and lacrosse player at Notre Dame. Haley continued her soccer career at East Stroudsburg University in PA. At ESU, Haley started all 84 games of her career and was a captain for 3 years, capturing the PSAC Championship in 2017.

* All-PSAC East 1st Team (2019)
* All-PSAC East 2nd Team (2017, 2018)
* All-PSAC 3rd Team (2017)
* United Soccer Coaches All-America 3rd Team (2019)
* United Soccer Coaches All-Region 1st Team (2019)
* United Soccer Coaches All-Region 2nd Team (2018)
* United Soccer Coaches All-Region 3rd Team (2017)
* D2 CCA All-Region 1st Team (2017, 2019)

Haley finished in the ESU history books:
* Tied for 9th in goals
* 10th in points
* 3rd in career starts

Territories

- South Jersey
- Massachusetts
- Maine
- Vermont